| Publications [#2667] of Ronald R. Butters
search trademarklinguistics.com.Essays/Articles/Chapters in Books
- "'We didn't realize that lite beer was supposed to suck!': The Putative Vulgarity of X sucks in American English." Dictionaries: Journal of the Dictionary Society of North America
(2001)
(last updated on 2008/01/21)
Author's Comments: Revision of a paper read at the meeting of the American Dialect
Society, Jan. 6, 2000
Abstract: On April 17, 1991, a twelve-year-old junior-high student in
Norfolk,
Virginia, was suspended from school for refusing to desist
from
wearing a tee shirt on the front of which was printed in
very large
letters, DRUGS SUCK! School officials argued that the
inscription
was "inappropriate for school attire" because it
is "vulgar," "derives
from a sexual connotation of oral-genital contact," and
hence is
potentially disruptive to the maintenance of order in
school. The
child's parents sued, insisting that the shirt contained a
valuable
message of critical importance and that the vernacular
language
was not "vulgar" but simply contemporary slang which
conveyed
the message in a powerful fashion to an otherwise quite
impervious audience.
The case presents a complex of problems in semiotics,
pragmatics, semantics, and historical linguistics. Most
speakers of
American English today know that "X Sucks!" has a primary
colloquial meaning "X is bad." However, many speakers also
attach secondary meanings and even putative etymologies to
the
slang phrase--usually connected to fellatio--which some of
them
may find deeply offensive; yet (unlike the Norfolk school
officials)
they have no difficulty accepting the phrase and even using
it
themselves.
The paper demonstrates (a). that the etymological
connection
between "X Sucks!" and fellatio is largely a folk
etymology; and (b).
that contemporary connotations of fellatio for "X Sucks!"
are
foregrounded only when the specific issue of putative
etymology is
raised, thus allowing speakers to accept a phrase that they
might
otherwise find inappropriate.
|