Thompson Writing Program Faculty Database
Thompson Writing Program
Arts & Sciences
Duke University

 HOME > Arts & Sciences > TWP > Faculty    Search Help Login pdf version printable version 

Publications [#325744] of Jesse S Summers

Papers Published

  1. Summers, JS. "Rationalizing our Way into Moral Progress." Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 20.1 (February, 2017): 93-104. [doi]
    (last updated on 2022/05/24)

    Abstract:
    Research suggests that the explicit reasoning we offer to ourselves and to others is often rationalization, that we act instead on instincts, inclinations, stereotypes, emotions, neurobiology, habits, reactions, evolutionary pressures, unexamined principles, or justifications other than the ones we think we’re acting on, then we tell a post hoc story to justify our actions. This is troubling for views of moral progress according to which moral progress proceeds from our engagement with our own and others’ reasons. I consider an account of rationalization, based on Robert Audi’s, to make clear that rationalization, unlike simple lying, can be sincere. Because it can be sincere, and because we also have a desire to be consistent with ourselves, I argue that rationalization sets us up for becoming better people over time, and that a similar case can be made to explain how moral progress among groups of people can proceed via rationalization.


Duke University * Arts & Sciences * TWP * Faculty * Staff * Reload * Login