Publications [#385721] of Steven G. Medema

Chapters in Books

1. Medema, SG, Non-welfarism in the Early Debates over the Coase Theorem: The Case of Environmental Economics*, in Welfare Theory Public Action and Ethical Values Revisiting the History of Welfare Economics (January, 2021), pp. 208-231 [doi]
   (last updated on 2026/01/09)

   Abstract:
   Though economists typically eschewed non-welfarist arguments in the post-WWII period, there is at least one prominent instance in which such arguments were very much in play, both directly and as underpinnings for welfare-related arguments: The debate over the Coase theorem. This debate saw the Coase theorem regularly challenged on both welfarist (efficiency) and non-welfarist grounds. This then raises the question of what it was about the Coase theorem that led economists into this non-welfarist territory. This essay revisits the early debates over the Coase theorem, where non-welfarist arguments featured prominently, in order to bring out the nature of those arguments and attempt to understand the rationale(s) for their deployment. As we shall see, this move was a function of forces internal and external to economics, including the environmental turn in society and the profession, a concern with issues of fairness and equity in the evaluation of how to resolve externality problems, and a view, prominent in certain quarters, that the environment and environmental preservation is an end in itself.