Journal Articles
- Köymen, B; O'Madagain, C; Domberg, A; Tomasello, M, Young Children's Ability to Produce Valid and Relevant Counter-Arguments.,
Child development, vol. 91 no. 3
(May, 2020),
pp. 685-693 [doi].
(last updated on 2024/08/25)
Abstract: In collaborative problem solving, children produce and evaluate arguments for proposals. We investigated whether 3- and 5-year-olds (N = 192) can produce and evaluate arguments against those arguments (i.e., counter-arguments). In Study 1, each child within a peer dyad was privately given a reason to prefer one over another solution to a task. One child, however, was given further information that would refute the reasoning of their partner. Five-year-olds, but not 3-year-olds, identified and produced valid and relevant counter-arguments. In Study 2, 3-year-olds were given discourse training (discourse that contrasted valid and invalid counter-arguments) and then given the same problem-solving tasks. After training, 3-year-olds could also identify and produce valid and relevant counter-arguments. Thus, participating in discourse about reasons facilitates children's counter-argumentation.
|